Action/Adventure(733)
Allegory(316)
Amish(4,975)
Biblical(1,095)
Children(894)
Classic Fiction(441)
Contemporary(9,487)
Drama(1,235)
Fantasy/Science Fiction(2,066)
Visionary(84)
Historical(3,037)
Poetry(12)
Prophecy & End Times(756)
Romance(15,209)
Short Stories(184)
Suspense & Intrigue(9,019)
Teens(1,065)
Westerns(864)
Shop Now At Christianbook.com
Shop Fantasy/Science Fiction or
Choose a Category
- Academic
- Accompaniment Tracks
- Advent
- Adventures in Odyssey ™
- Audiobooks
- Bible Accessories
- Bible Covers
- Bible Studies & Curriculum
- Bibles
- Blooming Bargains
- Books
- Catholic
- Children
- Christian Living
- Christmas
- Church & Pastoral
- Church Supplies
- Closeouts
- Clothing & Accessories
- Crafts & Recreation
- DVDs
- Download
- Easter
- Education
- Fall
- Family
- Father's Day
- Fiction
- Focus Magazines
- Focus Resource
- Focus Reviewed
- Focus on the Family
- Gift & Home
- Graduation
- Homeschool
- MP3 Music Downloads
- Mother's Day
- Music
- New Release
- Patriotic
- Pre-Order
- Radio Theatre
- Slightly Imperfect
- Software
- Spanish
- Spring
- Subscriptions
- Sunday School
- Teens
- Thanksgiving
- VBS
- Videos
- Winter
- eBooks
Customer Reviews for Bethany House A Cast of Stones, The Staff and the Sword Series #1
Bethany House A Cast of Stones, The Staff and the Sword Series #1
In the backwater village of Callowford, Errol Stone's search for a drink is interrupted by a church messenger who arrives with urgent missives for the hermit priest in the hills. Desperate for coin, Errol volunteers to deliver them but soon finds himself hunted by deadly assassins. Forced to flee with the priest and a small band of travelers, Errol soon learns he's joined a quest that could change the fate of his kingdom.
Average Customer Rating:
(20 Reviews) 20
Rating Snapshot (20 reviews)
5 stars
13
4 stars
6
3 stars
1
2 stars
0
1 star
0
19 out of 2095%customers would recommend this product to a friend.
Customer Reviews for A Cast of Stones, The Staff and the Sword Series #1
Review 1 for A Cast of Stones, The Staff and the Sword Series #1
Overall Rating:
Amazing!
Date:May 9, 2013
Quality:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Meets Expectations:
5
out of
5
I had very high hopes for A Cast of Stones by Patrick W. Carr. I wasn’t disappointed. Sometimes a book comes along that you didn’t know you were waiting for until you read it, and somehow your world is more complete. A Cast of Stones is one of those books. A fresh fantasy concept, an intriguing cast of characters, and one of the best-written anti-heroes I’ve ever run across make A Cast of Stones a true delight to read. 6 stars!!!
Share this review:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 2 for A Cast of Stones, The Staff and the Sword Series #1
Overall Rating:
Medieval Adventure and Intrigue
Date:April 29, 2013
Quality:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Meets Expectations:
5
out of
5
I’m not sure this book is one I would have picked up in a bookstore. On a whim I requested it for review and am thankful I did.
The Staff and the Sword: A Cast of Stones by Patrick W. Carr is a medieval fantasy that had me hooked from the first pages. The main character is so very human, his struggles are so much like our own – of his (and our) own making, and his depth of character is surprising. There are many twists and turns in the story and I struggled along with the main character about who to trust.
While not a big fantasy fan, this one was perfect! There was not too much “fantasy” and a whole lot of medieval – a great balance. The church has too much power, the kingdom hangs in the balance and the battle for power takes a toll on the people. The stones and a stone reader’s abilities were a fascinating portion of the story and I can’t wait for book two to find out how the story continues. Thankfully, the wait won’t be long. The Hero’s Lot will be released July 2013.
I give this book 5 stars out of 5.
Book has been provided courtesy of Baker Publishing Group and Graf-Martin Communications, Inc. Available at your favourite bookseller from Baker Books, a division of Baker Publishing Group.
Share this review:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 3 for A Cast of Stones, The Staff and the Sword Series #1
Overall Rating:
Fantasy with a Side of Self-Examination
Date:April 28, 2013
Quality:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Meets Expectations:
5
out of
5
A great frustration of many in the realm of Christian fiction is the lack of imagination or uniqueness. This may sound like a slightly exaggerated claim, but there is often a limit of Christian fiction that is not geared towards Amish romance, Old west romance, or murder and drama. None of these are a bad genre, or ones that should be dismissed or ignored, but these limit the appeal of Christian fiction. It is for this reason I was very excited when Bethany House announced the release of a new book by Patrick W. Carr A Cast of Stones: The Staff & The Sword.
Set in an almost middle age’s world, A Cast of Stones is a book that gets off to a quick start with action, adventure, and examination of life. This is the first book in a series that Patrick Carr is offering, and it seems to be a story that will excite and enthrall. The story begins with a young man by the name of Errol who sets out on what seems to be a simple task, and one that he has done many times, but that quickly takes twists and turns that young Errol could not expect.
As the story progresses many changes begin to happen to Errol as his identity and character are challenged, and he must either stay who he is, or become who he was destined to be while being confronted with insurmountable odds. Throughout this story Errol is challenged with a pain that he had spent year suppressing through drink. Errol is not only haunted by these great pains, but also sought after by enemies whom he does not know, and thrown apparently off track by events outside of his control.
Patrick Carr did more than just write intriguing fiction with Cast of Stones, instead he also offers character lessons and moral challenges. In its pages Carr creates a mirror for self-examination. It is for this reason that I give this book five stars for interest, intent, and intrigue. If you love fantasy and adventure, then Cast of Stones: The Staff & The Sword is a book worth reading.
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from Bethany House as part of their Blogger Review Program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commision’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
Share this review:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 4 for A Cast of Stones, The Staff and the Sword Series #1
Overall Rating:
Date:April 14, 2013
Quality:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Meets Expectations:
5
out of
5
Errol Stone is good at one thing: drinking himself into oblivion. Having the reputation of the town drunk of Callowford, his one goal in life is making another coin to pay for another night of loose living in the local tavern. Doing any and every odd job for the advancement of his vice, his ears perk up immediately upon the arrival of a nuntius who wishes to deliver letters to a hermit priest who lives in the forest. Despite everyone's doubts, Errol is determined to deliver his messages, collect his other half crown, and spend a week in the tavern nursing his habit.
But along his journey, he meets an assassin that will stop at nothing to take Errol's life. Bewildered and confused, Errol runs as fast and as far as he possibly can. Barely escaping with his life, he stumbles into the home of the hermit priest, Martin and his servant, Luis. Once he recounts his story and tells them the messages were ruined along the way, Martin and Luis begin packing to leave. Stunned at the turn of events and having no other choice but to go along with them, Errol is sucked into the mysterious quest that leaves him with more questions than answers. Compelled into service for the church, Errol has no choice but to go along for the ride. Will he prove himself to be a reader of stones and worthy to cast lots to save the kingdom? Or is he really just the useless drunkard that everyone believes him to be?
I was quite impressed by this novel, simply because whether you like fantasy fiction or not, you're going to love this tale of redemption, forgiveness, and second chances. I've always avoided this genre simply because of the magic, sorcery, superstition, and nonsense that seems to accompany this kind of story. But Carr made this a humorous, believable tale that kept my interest up till the last page. I am anticipating the next installment in the series, and would recommend Carr's first novel to teenagers and adults alike.
This book was provided by the publisher for free in exchange for an honest review.
Share this review:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 5 for A Cast of Stones, The Staff and the Sword Series #1
Overall Rating:
Welcome to a new voice in YA fantasy!
Date:April 10, 2013
Carol Gehringer
Location:Raleigh, NC
Age:55-65
Gender:female
Quality:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Meets Expectations:
5
out of
5
Patrick Carr makes his debut with an epic fantasy that will engage readers as they venture into the world Carr creates, one on the brink of destruction where adventure awaits a reluctant hero.
In A Cast of Stones, Errol is the village drunk, not the sort of person you expect to do heroic deeds. Errol drowns his sorrows in ale, doing occasional errands to earn enough coin to buy more ale. He is hired by a church messenger to take an official communication to a recluse priest living in a rustic area. A simple delivery becomes deadly as an assassin hunts him down. He scarcely makes it alive to Pater’s home but the letters are too damaged to read. Errol, Pater Martin and Luis hurry to reach the church messenger in the village. They are poisoned from the bread Errol brought from the village. Errol barely manages to get help in time. That’s when their troubles really begin.
Once in the village, the church messenger gives Pater the message verbally. It requests that Pater travel to Erinon to meet with the others to cast the stones for the king’s successor. But they face danger along the way. Errol discovers he can read the stones Luis casts. His new talent requires him to serve the church as a reader. Errol gives up his taste for ale, learns to read and fight, as he journeys to his new life. But someone is killing the readers in the church.
Carr’s debut novel is filled with strong characters and a tightly-woven plot. Errol’s story continues in The Hero’s Lot (summer 2013).
Highly recommended for teen collections in public libraries and school libraries.
Disclaimer: Book reviews are my opinion of books I either purchased or received free of cost from the publisher in exchange for a honest review.
Share this review:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 6 for A Cast of Stones, The Staff and the Sword Series #1
Overall Rating:
ALL the potential of J.R.R TOlkien!!!
Date:April 7, 2013
Beth
Location:N.C
Age:18-24
Gender:female
Quality:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Meets Expectations:
5
out of
5
Disclaimer-*This book is so extraordinary I'm afraid my review will fall embarrassingly short in it's description.*
Young Errol Stone is little more than a drunk doing anything to earn an extra crown for ale until one day a mysterious messenger sends him with a letter that nearly ends in his assassination.
King Rodran is dying and their is no heir to the throne. It will be up to the Readers to reveal the next king but they are disappearing at an alarming rate! Errol sets out for the capital, Erinon, with his friends Martin and Luis, a priest and a Reader, and Liam, the perceived future king.
However it is Errol that is being hunted by unknown assassins and otherworldly beasts. But why?
Their enemies obviously know something they don't!
I absolutely cannot believe this is Patrick W. Carr's first book!! If you like fantasy, medieval, or even historical fiction, you will LOVE this book! I can't recommend A Cast of Stones enough!!!!
In my opinion Patrick Carr has all the potential of J.R.R Tolkien!!
Young Errol Stone is little more than a drunk doing anything to earn an extra crown for ale until one day a mysterious messenger sends him with a letter that nearly ends in his assassination.
King Rodran is dying and their is no heir to the throne. It will be up to the Readers to reveal the next king but they are disappearing at an alarming rate! Errol sets out for the capital, Erinon, with his friends Martin and Luis, a priest and a Reader, and Liam, the perceived future king.
However it is Errol that is being hunted by unknown assassins and otherworldly beasts. But why?
Their enemies obviously know something they don't!
I absolutely cannot believe this is Patrick W. Carr's first book!! If you like fantasy, medieval, or even historical fiction, you will LOVE this book! I can't recommend A Cast of Stones enough!!!!
In my opinion Patrick Carr has all the potential of J.R.R Tolkien!!
I received this book free from Bethany House in exchange for an honest review.
Share this review:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 7 for A Cast of Stones, The Staff and the Sword Series #1
Overall Rating:
An Awesome Tale of an Unlikely Hero!
Date:March 28, 2013
Wman4JC
Location:miami, fl
Age:25-34
Gender:female
Quality:
4
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Meets Expectations:
4
out of
5
My Review
I love the cover of this book and even though it’s intensely well written, the plot of Errol’s story didn’t grab me until 100 pages into the book. Errol is an orphan and at age 18 has been the town drunk for years, but one day he gets an opportunity to deliver a very important message and his destiny changes upon making the decision. Here is what Errol learns on his journey:
I love the cover of this book and even though it’s intensely well written, the plot of Errol’s story didn’t grab me until 100 pages into the book. Errol is an orphan and at age 18 has been the town drunk for years, but one day he gets an opportunity to deliver a very important message and his destiny changes upon making the decision. Here is what Errol learns on his journey:
How to escape arrows/archers/assassins
How to read stones/become a reader (someone who is like a prophet, they exist only within the power of the church)
What it feels like to be under a compulsion (going in a certain direction)
How to fight poison with healing herbs
How to get up at dawn for traveling (I’m a late sleeper so I understood his struggle there)
How to ride a horse
Errol has no education, but learns to read in his journey
What it’s like to be under Deas’s touch/favor (the word used for God in the plot)
How to survive a near drowning
How to fight with a staff (think Moses or Gandalf here)
How to overcome an addiction
How to guard a master caravan/get promoted among skilled fighters
How to learn an opponent’s weakness
Errol learns to bargain in trading goods
How to face injustice
How to decipher corruption
How to fight for a kingdom
How to read stones/become a reader (someone who is like a prophet, they exist only within the power of the church)
What it feels like to be under a compulsion (going in a certain direction)
How to fight poison with healing herbs
How to get up at dawn for traveling (I’m a late sleeper so I understood his struggle there)
How to ride a horse
Errol has no education, but learns to read in his journey
What it’s like to be under Deas’s touch/favor (the word used for God in the plot)
How to survive a near drowning
How to fight with a staff (think Moses or Gandalf here)
How to overcome an addiction
How to guard a master caravan/get promoted among skilled fighters
How to learn an opponent’s weakness
Errol learns to bargain in trading goods
How to face injustice
How to decipher corruption
How to fight for a kingdom
What do I learn from Errol’s story? I didn’t get attached to his character until later in this story, but I was amazed at his ability to survive in any situation and his resilience. He is the most ignorant protagonist I have witnessed in fiction, but he’s a FAST learner and as he realizes where he belongs in the story he becomes legendary in the kingdom. Watching his transformation in the story blessed me more than I anticipated, it gave me hope as well as entertainment.
I learned that not every character turns out the way you believe they will. Your rivals/enemies can become your closest friends and allies; someone you think is trustworthy can quickly become a betrayer.
Greed is a powerful element in Errol’s journey. It never touches him, but it affects everyone around him for better or for worse.
When God is in control of your destiny, whether you’re aware of this or not or even welcome it, GREAT things are possible.
I thought Errol would travel with the same characters throughout the book, but instead he comes across three different circumstances before he reaches his destination. His transformation is completed before he arrives and that makes the journey more important than the point he’s trying to reach. Some books are frustrating when written like that, Carr does it brilliantly and masterfully as if he’s taken this journey himself.
Honor as well as skill makes a great warrior. Errol works hard and is determined to do the right thing even when he has no choices. I was in amazement when he overcame his addiction. There are men in this book who are skilled fighters, but some of them have no honor.
There is some romance within the story, but it’s mostly action and battles. Errol learns to balance his fighting techniques and prefers to halt a fight than deliberately maim an opponent. He had my admiration and respect there as well. I pictured him to be like a ninja with his staff, but his movements are graceful as well as deadly.
There is an epilogue at the end that illustrates a sequel will be available soon, but even if this reviewer doesn’t continue with the rest of the saga I take great pleasure at seeing Errol’s journey conclude the way it does. I was utterly moved at the end, I wish all books had such an ending for characters like Errol. They learn meekness in the midst of survival and they take the humble attitude when facing injustices. I have a feeling that Errol will continue to succeed even when the stones say otherwise.
I want to thank Bethany House for the review copy they provided. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own.
Share this review:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 8 for A Cast of Stones, The Staff and the Sword Series #1
Overall Rating:
Excellent!
Date:March 26, 2013
Quality:
4
out of
5
Value:
4
out of
5
Meets Expectations:
4
out of
5
Errol, an apprentice, yet but a boy, is enroute to Martin Pater to deliver an important message. He is met by many dangerous obstacles including a man in black. At the tender age of 14 he is consumed by the desire for strong drink while he harbors bitter memories of his childhood. Errol is about to fight the battle of darkness in the quest of knowledge and strength against those who look for weakness. Will success find an end or will he be stopped from accomplishment?
A tale of medieval fantasy, battles and loyalty from a time not of our own. Rich with descriptive scenery, well developed and interesting characters and engaging easy to follow dialogue. I read this book in sections, due to the lengthiness, and many times I found that when reading I could picture myself within the pages witnessing the action first hand! Plot progressed slowly as high action took place, while welcoming the next book in the series. I was entertained by this faith challenging read and will highly recommend it to others especially those who enjoy a creative fantasy! Excellent first novel solid 4 Stars! I received a complimentary copy from Bethany House Publishers for my review.
Share this review:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 9 for A Cast of Stones, The Staff and the Sword Series #1
Overall Rating:
High Fantasy at its best
Date:March 16, 2013
Gringa93
Location:Minneapolis, MN
Quality:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Meets Expectations:
5
out of
5
Errol Stone, an orphan and town drunk, is tapped for an adventure that changes his life. Errol is asked to deliver a message to a priest in order to gain enough coin to pay for the ale he so desperately craves. Errol soon finds himself running for his life. People and creatures are attacking him wanting to end his life and he doesn't know why. Errol soon learns to defend himself not with the sword, but the stick. With the patience and precision of a warrior, he soon learns how to defend himself and best some of the best swordsmen in a traveling merchantman's caravan. Follow Errol on this grand adventure to learn how he ends up impressing and defending a king.
This high fantasy is written in the style of Tolkien's The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings. I found this book to be like a train pulling out of a station, it slowly gathered steam until it was roaring down the tracks at full steam. I wish that I had the second installment of this story to read right now. The cast of characters is long and detailed. I loved how Carr was able to introduce so many characters and bring the reader to understanding and wanting to learn more at the end of this book. I loved the action that he brought about with a simple flick of the word and sword. I was taken by surprise with some of the attacks just as a warrior might be taken by surprise. The details of the story helped to move the action along. I loved how the final battle came to a stunning conclusion and then wrapped up with the reader asking questions about who will take the throne when the king dies. This book was a great adventure and I want to read more.
Thank you to Bethany House Publishers for providing me with this book to read and review.
Share this review:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 10 for A Cast of Stones, The Staff and the Sword Series #1
Overall Rating:
An Excellent Fantasy
Date:March 14, 2013
Quality:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Meets Expectations:
5
out of
5
The fantasy genre is a favorite of mine and this book was a great read. I like that its not written for middle schoolers but geared to adults. I felt really invested in these characters by the end of the book and I look forward to reading the next in the series. The main character Errol goes from being an orphaned drunk with no purpose in life to the hero of the story. I love the change he goes through and how it flowed through the book. There was the right amount of action, adventure and imagination. I was glad they left the romance element out of the first book as there was enough happening without adding that to the story. If you enjoy fantasy, this is well worth the read.
I received this book free from Bethany House in exchange for my review.
Share this review:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 11 for A Cast of Stones, The Staff and the Sword Series #1
Overall Rating:
mixed feelings
Date:March 9, 2013
Quality:
4
out of
5
Value:
4
out of
5
Meets Expectations:
3
out of
5
I love Christian fantasy novels, especially lengthy ones! The story begins with Errol the village drunk with no ambition in life other than getting some $ to stay intoxicated. When he is randomly chosen to deliver an epic message to the kingdom, which brings some purpose to his life. I found it hard to connect with Errol, in my opinion, he seemed a very naive, careless, loser. I did like some of the mysteries in the first half of the book, but I was constantly torn between the characters. Perhaps male readers will connect better with them, but for me they didn't steal my heart really, and I'm sure Errol will redeem himself in the second book, but I doubt I'll read it. It's hard to explain how I felt, I wanted to feel for him, but it lacked giving me sympathy for the supposed 'hero'. I really did try to like it though, sorry.
*I received this book free from the Publisher in exchange for an unbiased, non-profit, honest review*
Share this review:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 12 for A Cast of Stones, The Staff and the Sword Series #1
Overall Rating:
Assassins, An Aging King, A Quest and Redemption
Date:March 9, 2013
Quality:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Meets Expectations:
5
out of
5
Patrick W. Carr in his new book, “A Cast Of Stones” Book One in The Staff & The Sword series published by Bethany House brings us into the life of Errol Stone.
From the back cover: The Fate of the Kingdom Awaits the Cast of Stones
In the backwater village of Callowford, roustabout Errol Stone is enlisted by a church messenger arriving with urgent missives for the hermit priest in the hills. Eager for coin, Errol agrees to what he thinks will be an easy task, but soon finds himself hunted by deadly assassins. Forced to flee with the priest and a small band of travelers, Errol soon learns he’s joined a quest that could change the fate of his kingdom.
Protected for millennia by the heirs of the first king, the kingdom’s dynasty nears its end and the selection of the new king begins–but in secret and shadow. As danger mounts, Errol must leave behind the stains and griefs of the past, learn to fight, and discover who is hunting him and his companions and how far they will go to stop the reading of the stones.
I think that any story where the hero’s name is Errol Stone has to be a winner and, since, “A Cast of Stones” has Errol Stone as its hero then I am correct. This is a story about redemption as Errol, an orphan and the town drunk, takes an assignment to deliver a message to the hermit priest. It never occurred to him that this would be the start of a grand adventure it was just a way to make some money for ale. However, the quest begins as assassins try to kill Errol and the priest. Eventually this journey will take him before the aging king and the kingdom leaders. This is grand storytelling that has many facets to it and is meant to be enjoyed and savored. Don’t hurry through the reading, even though you will want to, as there are many levels of story to take in. Plus Mr. Carr has great fun with the names he uses, I particularly like the mentor team of Martin and Luis, bu that is me. Patrick W. Carr is an amazing writer and, in “A Cast of Stones”, has given us a work that will have us thinking long after we have finished reading the book. I am really looking forward to book two.
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from Bethany House Publishers. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 : “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
Share this review:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 13 for A Cast of Stones, The Staff and the Sword Series #1
Overall Rating:
a well written Christian based fantasy
Date:March 6, 2013
Quality:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Meets Expectations:
5
out of
5
For me to give a Christian fantasy novel high marks, it must have several characteristics. This novel does.
Errol Stone is a young man “in the ale barrel.” He lives to earn enough to buy his next tankard. He is an orphan and the source of jokes for the medieval village.
But when Errol is asked to deliver a message to hermit priest, the adventure of his life begins. He finds he is hunted by deadly assassins. He manages to deliver the message then flees with the priest and his fellows of support.
Errol has a gift that is essential to the preservation of the kingdom. When he is separated from his traveling companions, he knows he must find his way to the capitol. But there are supernatural powers that do all they can to stop him.
But when Errol is asked to deliver a message to hermit priest, the adventure of his life begins. He finds he is hunted by deadly assassins. He manages to deliver the message then flees with the priest and his fellows of support.
Errol has a gift that is essential to the preservation of the kingdom. When he is separated from his traveling companions, he knows he must find his way to the capitol. But there are supernatural powers that do all they can to stop him.
Many times in Christian fiction, the allusion to Christianity is so convoluted it is hardly recognized. That is not the case here. The allusions to Christianity are clear and well presented.
Another aspect of fantasy I require is simplicity, that is, not so many odd names, characters, and abilities that I get lost. Carr has done his job of creating a kingdom and people very well. The story was enjoyable because I could stay with Errol in his travels and not get sidetracked by so many odd creations.
Another aspect of fantasy I require is simplicity, that is, not so many odd names, characters, and abilities that I get lost. Carr has done his job of creating a kingdom and people very well. The story was enjoyable because I could stay with Errol in his travels and not get sidetracked by so many odd creations.
And the end of this first novel in the series made me want more. I look forward to reading Carr's next novel to find out Errol's role in saving the kingdom.
I received a complimentary egalley of this book from the publisher for the purpose of this review.
Share this review:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 14 for A Cast of Stones, The Staff and the Sword Series #1
Overall Rating:
Redemption and good discussion.
Date:March 5, 2013
Quality:
4
out of
5
Value:
4
out of
5
Meets Expectations:
4
out of
5
The premise of the book was a young man known for drunkenness, too thin, no good with a sword, pressed into service for the Church and the Kingdom.
I love Tolkien and Lewis and I have been nourished by their stories. I eagerly requested this book, for it is a joy to find a new author who writes long, rich fantasy. I took out my highlighter and began marking passages.
The discussion between Martin and Luis shows us a glimpse into the main character.
"He sleeps," Martin said. "If I'd had to cross the gorge with someone shooting arrows at me, I'd sleep for a month."
Luis snorted "Yes, as would I, but we're no longer young. Errol lies at the dawn of his prime."
"Prime? The boy hasn't had much chance at a prime. Look at him. He's a handbreath shorter than Liam and thin as a wafer. A young man his age should not be so lean."
Luis snorted "Yes, as would I, but we're no longer young. Errol lies at the dawn of his prime."
"Prime? The boy hasn't had much chance at a prime. Look at him. He's a handbreath shorter than Liam and thin as a wafer. A young man his age should not be so lean."
I found myself hoping for redemption for Errol. The scene when Martin and Luis begin helping Errol to heal by ministering tiny morsels of bread and sips of communion wine throughout the long night was a scene of compassion.
I think it is safe to say redemption was the focus of this story. : )
There is a scene almost at the end, when Martin presents the account of Errol's courage- and says "I knew not the depth of courage that resided in Errol Stone. Stripped by fate of family, name and dignity, he triumphed still. Can any deny God's favor? I am humbled by his perseverance and fortitude."
Errol's response to this praise is one of humility, and Martin says "Some men are more easily broken by kindness than censure, the kingdom has need of such men." This is a good scene. : )
And with sequels coming, there will be time to explore Errol's place in the Kingdom.
There is a scene almost at the end, when Martin presents the account of Errol's courage- and says "I knew not the depth of courage that resided in Errol Stone. Stripped by fate of family, name and dignity, he triumphed still. Can any deny God's favor? I am humbled by his perseverance and fortitude."
Errol's response to this praise is one of humility, and Martin says "Some men are more easily broken by kindness than censure, the kingdom has need of such men." This is a good scene. : )
And with sequels coming, there will be time to explore Errol's place in the Kingdom.
I thought I wouldn't able to finish this book however.
I just read the death scene of Errol's mentor and can't continue. I just can't do it. I just read three "murder mysteries" by Randy Alcorn, and I was less frightened by those books than that scene.
I just read the death scene of Errol's mentor and can't continue. I just can't do it. I just read three "murder mysteries" by Randy Alcorn, and I was less frightened by those books than that scene.
There are a lot of questions raised in this book, questions that make for a long discussion.
What do the 'lots' mean? In the OT, lots were cast to determine certain things and it was understood that God directed the lots.
Is God directing the lots in this book?
Is the "reader" gifted by God with the ability to make lots, to serve God?
Or is this divination?
What do the 'lots' mean? In the OT, lots were cast to determine certain things and it was understood that God directed the lots.
Is God directing the lots in this book?
Is the "reader" gifted by God with the ability to make lots, to serve God?
Or is this divination?
Why was Martin nearly nude in the glen and making jokes about it? Was that Martin's theology of clothing- little needed?
What about the themes of possession? Who are the healers talking to? Due to these themes, this book is one to be discussed. Really, that is the point of Christian reading: To enjoy a story *and* to think for the glory of God.
Is the "church" the church, or a corrupt false church? What about its servants?
Women guards in the caravan- co-ed warfare? Or plain temptation for men? What will Errol do when he is offered a way to advance as a caravan guard- by fighting two women? Does sparring a woman teach a man to protect one?
I think there is more freedom for adventure in a group of all men. The women and men together cause too much distraction from the mission. Having a merchant's daughter in the caravan made sense, I wish she wasn't a guard though. I would give the women a different role in the adventure. A band of brothers such as in Fellowship of the Ring gives us a good chance to appreciate something almost lost these days- good, manly friendships.
The seduction of Errol by Rohka, the merchants daughter, was troubling, as it was supposed to be. She was using Errol, and her father was using her. What, exactly, does "I meant every kiss- but you're not the one for me," mean? Did she even know?
Errol will need to learn one of the first lessons of good men- guard your heart and your eyes. Proverbs seven women lurk. Like the peasants daughter who essentially said she would like to see our hero unclothed. That, Errol, is not flattery, it is sin.
He will need to learn to run from sin like Joseph did when Potiphar's wife went after him, and to be repulsed by this request, not intrigued.
Errol will need to learn one of the first lessons of good men- guard your heart and your eyes. Proverbs seven women lurk. Like the peasants daughter who essentially said she would like to see our hero unclothed. That, Errol, is not flattery, it is sin.
He will need to learn to run from sin like Joseph did when Potiphar's wife went after him, and to be repulsed by this request, not intrigued.
Errol has lessons to learn, and he is by no means done. The Kingdom needs Good (Redeemed) Men, and I think Errol will be one of those men.
I received this book from Bethany House for a review.
Share this review:
+2points
2of 2voted this as helpful.
Review 15 for A Cast of Stones, The Staff and the Sword Series #1
Overall Rating:
Drunkard Turned Hero
Date:February 17, 2013
CTF Devourer
Location:CTF Devourer
Age:25-34
Gender:female
Quality:
4
out of
5
Value:
3
out of
5
Meets Expectations:
5
out of
5
"Can you shoot?"
He nodded. "I know how it's done, but I'm not a very good shot," he confessed.
Cruk sighed, squeezed his eyes closed, "Don't you do anything well besides drink?"
"I never really needed to learn. Nobody's ever tried to kill me before. Now it's happened twice in one day."
He nodded. "I know how it's done, but I'm not a very good shot," he confessed.
Cruk sighed, squeezed his eyes closed, "Don't you do anything well besides drink?"
"I never really needed to learn. Nobody's ever tried to kill me before. Now it's happened twice in one day."
Book: A Cast Of Stones by Patrick W. Carr, Bethany House Publishers, 2013
Genre: Fantasy/Allegory
Target Audience: Boys 13+
Subjects: Showing love to others, alcohol
Summary: He's the village drunk for goodness sakes! The local priest has put him in the stocks plenty of times. The citizens of his town rely on his craving for ale. They know how predictable he is. Errol never intended to get mixed up in the Church. He simply agreed to deliver a message one day. The man who gave him the message was paying him well and he knows the trails better than anyone. And his desire to spend his earnings on drink will guarantee his return. Yet, the next thing he knows, he's under a compulsion to turn himself in to the Church to present himself as a reader - a highly important role in the kingdom! A number of near death escapes later puts him at an old farmhouse learning to use the staff. A number of battles later eventually get him to the city to obey the compulsion put on him. When he arrives though, he finds nothing is as he thought and he is a pawn in a deadly game of survival. What's at stake? Nothing less than the entire kingdom itself!
Notes: The first in a new series promoted as an "epic medieval saga fantasy readers will love", A Cast of Stones, tells the story of a young man's rise from the status of town drunk, to one of the most important people in the entire kingdom. A reluctant hero, Errol simply fights for survival and freedom. What he most longs for though is companionship - family and friends. There are definitely spiritual references in this book. A number of the main characters serve the Church and swear by or pray to "The Three". At one point, the story of God's sending Christ to earth and His death for our sins is allegorically told as they share the kingdom's history with Errorl. The best spiritual reference is actually the night Errol stays with the priest he delivered a message to. Not having gone this long without a drink in years, he is sick the whole night through, but rather than the judgment and condemnation like he receives from his local church leader, this priest shows compassion and grace, promising and following through on the promise, to help Errol through the night. I don't, however, see a strong lesson that is being taught. The spiritual elements are more a part of the culture for the characters, sort of the setting.
Spiritual Content Recommendation Scale: 3/5
Quality and Enjoyment Recommendation Scale: 4/5
Reviewer: J:-)mi
Genre: Fantasy/Allegory
Target Audience: Boys 13+
Subjects: Showing love to others, alcohol
Summary: He's the village drunk for goodness sakes! The local priest has put him in the stocks plenty of times. The citizens of his town rely on his craving for ale. They know how predictable he is. Errol never intended to get mixed up in the Church. He simply agreed to deliver a message one day. The man who gave him the message was paying him well and he knows the trails better than anyone. And his desire to spend his earnings on drink will guarantee his return. Yet, the next thing he knows, he's under a compulsion to turn himself in to the Church to present himself as a reader - a highly important role in the kingdom! A number of near death escapes later puts him at an old farmhouse learning to use the staff. A number of battles later eventually get him to the city to obey the compulsion put on him. When he arrives though, he finds nothing is as he thought and he is a pawn in a deadly game of survival. What's at stake? Nothing less than the entire kingdom itself!
Notes: The first in a new series promoted as an "epic medieval saga fantasy readers will love", A Cast of Stones, tells the story of a young man's rise from the status of town drunk, to one of the most important people in the entire kingdom. A reluctant hero, Errol simply fights for survival and freedom. What he most longs for though is companionship - family and friends. There are definitely spiritual references in this book. A number of the main characters serve the Church and swear by or pray to "The Three". At one point, the story of God's sending Christ to earth and His death for our sins is allegorically told as they share the kingdom's history with Errorl. The best spiritual reference is actually the night Errol stays with the priest he delivered a message to. Not having gone this long without a drink in years, he is sick the whole night through, but rather than the judgment and condemnation like he receives from his local church leader, this priest shows compassion and grace, promising and following through on the promise, to help Errol through the night. I don't, however, see a strong lesson that is being taught. The spiritual elements are more a part of the culture for the characters, sort of the setting.
Spiritual Content Recommendation Scale: 3/5
Quality and Enjoyment Recommendation Scale: 4/5
Reviewer: J:-)mi
1 Peter 2:5 - You also, like living stones, are being built into a spiritual house to be a holy priesthood, offering spiritual sacrifices acceptable to God through Jesus Christ.
Thank you to Bethany House Publishers for providing me with a free copy of this book to review.
Share this review:
+1point
1of 1voted this as helpful.
Review 16 for A Cast of Stones, The Staff and the Sword Series #1
Overall Rating:
A fantasy that won't make grandma blush!
Date:February 14, 2013
Quality:
4
out of
5
Value:
4
out of
5
Meets Expectations:
4
out of
5
If you are looking for a well-written fantasy novel, then "A Cast of Stones" may just be for you. It's a fantasy that even your grandma will approve of (there's not fifty shades of anything in THIS book).
Featuring a world conceived with great imagination, Patrick W. Carr's "A Cast of Stones" is an epic fantasy tale sure to delight savvy readers. Once I'd read enough of the story to wrap myself around the world the author has invented, I found myself pleasantly surprised with the pacing of the story and the intense action scenes that unfolded. The deeper into the story I went, the more engaged I was until by the end I was entirely caught up in the plot to see what Errol was in for next! The author's descriptions are sharp and clear, and he displays a keen ability to bring a story to life, weaving together fantasy and mystery and intrigue. I love the character of Errol, one of those characters who you have immediate sympathy for, while also reflecting our own struggles in life to feel significant and that your life has worth. The book is fairly long at well over 400 pages, and perhaps could have been tightened up a bit (although I also admit it's hard to imagine what the author would take out). Overall it is a grand start to the author's writing career, and is worthy entertainment indeed.
I am definitely looking forward to what is coming next in the series. Readers who enjoy works by Stephen Lawhead will surely enjoy "A Cast of Stones". I give this book a solid recommendation and award it 4 out of 5 stars.
Book has been provided courtesy of Baker Publishing Group and Graf-Martin Communications, Inc. Available at your favourite bookseller from Bethany House, a division of Baker Publishing Group.
Share this review:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
Review 17 for A Cast of Stones, The Staff and the Sword Series #1
Overall Rating:
A Must Read For Fantasy Fans!!!
Date:February 10, 2013
Liz R
Location:Hayden, Al
Age:18-24
Gender:female
Quality:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Meets Expectations:
5
out of
5
A Cast of Stones begins with Errol Stone, the town drunk, in search of his next drink. Little does he know, when he agrees to deliver a letter for a church messenger that his life will never be the same again.
Patrick Carr’s debut novel is full of action, danger, magic and some great characters. Errol is not your typical hero. At the start of the novel he is controlled by his vice and is full of self doubt, little self worth and has never journeyed beyond Callowford or the neighboring town of Berea. As the story progresses, he discovers his true value and realizes he is strong enough to handle the responsibilities placed on him, whatever they may be. There is also a strong cast of supporting characters who make the story that much better.
As a fantasy addict I knew I would enjoy this novel and I was not disappointed. The writing was fantastic and the story kept me up well into the night. A Cast of Stones is a must read for fantasy fans and I’m looking forward to the sequel, The Hero’s Lot!
***I received a copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own***
Share this review:
+1point
1of 1voted this as helpful.
Review 18 for A Cast of Stones, The Staff and the Sword Series #1
Overall Rating:
Fantastic tale of hope and redemption
Date:January 29, 2013
Quality:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Meets Expectations:
5
out of
5
I’ll be honest—I was scared to read this book but it sounded SO interesting! I know you’re all probably wondering why I was scared but I haven’t had the best of luck reading books by debut authors. This one was a very pleasant surprise! I’m very shocked that this is the first published work by this author. This story is a fantasy story but it reads more like a knight’s tale rather than out and out fantasy. That isn’t saying it is not a fantasy setting but I think that a person who may not enjoy the typical wizards and magic may actually really enjoy this book.
About the Story:
Errol wishes to drown his sorrow in a barrel of ale and often does so until an attempt is made on his life. This is where things got very interesting. There was a fantasy twist but it read more like a medieval tale. As Errol is trying to overcome his fondness of ale—he is thrust into a role of being a “reader” by the church. This is pretty darn confusing to Errol as he doesn’t know how to read a letter, much less how to cast a mystical lot that only he can read! The idea of the lots was an interesting one to me. Some people it seems were born with the ability to carve a round sphere while forming a question and answer in their mind—once cast and drawn the lot would reveal the correct answer to the reader. Something is special about Errol’s ability as a reader but even he is unaware of how valuable he is. This story was one of self-discovery and overcoming odds to be the best person you can be. It provided an unlikely character the hope of becoming a great hero and should serve as a reminder that all heroes are ordinary people that have overcame extraordinary odds. If you’re looking for one fantasy story to read this year I would say this one is it. I gave this book a 4 star ratting—really it was closer to 4.5 but alas, good reads recognizes only whole stars. The only reason I went with a 4 star rating is because it took me awhile for me to really get into it. Once I did though I really did enjoy it very much so don’t let my 4 star rating deter you in any way!
Errol wishes to drown his sorrow in a barrel of ale and often does so until an attempt is made on his life. This is where things got very interesting. There was a fantasy twist but it read more like a medieval tale. As Errol is trying to overcome his fondness of ale—he is thrust into a role of being a “reader” by the church. This is pretty darn confusing to Errol as he doesn’t know how to read a letter, much less how to cast a mystical lot that only he can read! The idea of the lots was an interesting one to me. Some people it seems were born with the ability to carve a round sphere while forming a question and answer in their mind—once cast and drawn the lot would reveal the correct answer to the reader. Something is special about Errol’s ability as a reader but even he is unaware of how valuable he is. This story was one of self-discovery and overcoming odds to be the best person you can be. It provided an unlikely character the hope of becoming a great hero and should serve as a reminder that all heroes are ordinary people that have overcame extraordinary odds. If you’re looking for one fantasy story to read this year I would say this one is it. I gave this book a 4 star ratting—really it was closer to 4.5 but alas, good reads recognizes only whole stars. The only reason I went with a 4 star rating is because it took me awhile for me to really get into it. Once I did though I really did enjoy it very much so don’t let my 4 star rating deter you in any way!
Share this review:
+1point
1of 1voted this as helpful.
Review 19 for A Cast of Stones, The Staff and the Sword Series #1
Overall Rating:
An extraordinary medieval saga by new author!
Date:January 7, 2013
Quality:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Meets Expectations:
5
out of
5
I like a good fantasy, especially one that takes me to a different place and time. I also like to read and review new books by debuting authors. So writing this review is going to be fun and I hope you will find it more than helpful.
Now, when I read a subtitle that has a number one in it that tells me there are going to be more books in that particular series, therefore, that book better be a great book for me to consider reading any more of that series.
Well, let me tell you... A Cast of Stones is not only a great book, it is absolutely fantastic. Fantasy is not an easy genre to write in, there are few, in my humble opinion, who can really do it justice. To name three of my favorite fantasy writers, J.R.R. Tolkien, C.S. Lewis (for the classic fantasy) and C.S. Lakin (The Gates of Heaven Series - the current); if you have read anything by any one of these mighty authors, then like me, you have a high standard. It makes it difficult for those breaking into the genre.
Carr has not only broken into it by this extremely well-written tale that takes place in medieval time, but he delivers a story that will capture your imagination. His characters are flawless, strong, and his hero is someone anyone can relate to. Errol Stone starts out his life with nothing, an orphan, no ambition other than to earn enough to "stay in the cups." Little does he know, there is something special about himself and he has to go through many trials to determine what it is.
The plotting is superb. Carr's attention to detail in his plotting, characters, and places paints a vivid picture in the reader's mind. I was totally captured in the story, experiencing what Errol was going through, emotionally.
This book is going to sit next to my The Gates of Heaven Series, The Chronicles of Narnia and The Lord of the Rings. I am going to make room for the rest of this new author and his wonderful saga. Might I suggest, you better make room on your bookshelves for this saga, as well.
Bethany House, a division of Baker Publishing Group, provided me with a free review copy for the purpose of writing this review. I am not obligated to write a positive review.
Share this review:
+1point
1of 1voted this as helpful.
Review 20 for A Cast of Stones, The Staff and the Sword Series #1
Overall Rating:
Awesome Medieval Fantasy
Date:February 20, 2013
Retha
Location:South Africa
Age:45-54
Gender:female
Quality:
5
out of
5
Value:
5
out of
5
Meets Expectations:
5
out of
5
A Cast of Stones is an awesome medieval fantasy story. Thankfully when I turned the last page, I realised A Cast of Stones is the first in a series –there is more to come!
Errol Stone, the village drunk, takes a message to a hermit priest in the hills. His motivation was the coin he would receive for his effort. Instead of returning before nightfall with enough money to stay drunk for a week, he is hunted by an assassin on route and almost killed before he could deliver the message.
Errol’s life changes drastically when he has no option but to flee for his life, and join the quest that changes, not only his life, but the fate of the kingdom.
A Cast of Stones is a glorious fantasy story with plots twisting in directions you do not expect; the most unlikely become heroes, the villains are devious and tricky, then there are the priests, the guards and of course the king. There is enough danger and twists to keep you on edge, and enough wisdom to keep your hopes up.
I highly recommend A Cast of Stones. A Cast of Stones is a great book to read by all fantasy lovers. I invite those who do not care for the fantasy genre, but enjoy a good plot and like to dream of heroes, to put your toes into the water and to read A Cast of Stones.
The message I received from A Cast of Stones is –you are born with the calling God has placed on your life. No circumstances and no enemy will take your calling away. The enemy or circumstances can divert you from your chosen path, but it cannot destroy the calling.
Baker Publishing House Group / Bethany House Publishers as part of their media review bloggers program provided this eBook to me for free in exchange for this honest review.
Share this review:
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.