Very well written and appropriate for middle school girls. The situations are humorous and poignant, but they also seem very realistic. I think most "tween" girls will relate to Kate and her friends. The book has a great message about godly living for young girls without beating them over the head with it. It has great discussion questions in the back to encourage deeper reflection. I can't wait to pass this on to my friends with girls this age and to read the other Secret Keeper Girl books!

I did like this book, but it may not be as good as some of the lily books by nancy rue. I have it and the rest of the series about how 4 girls form this club through detention and each story is about the same thing, just different points of view.