The youngest and last unmarried of four sisters, Rachel HartHartzler spends most of her time helping with barn chores. Her role abruptly changes when her father hires Jordan Engles, the son he always wanted. As Jordan takes on brotherly roles around the house, like escorting Rachel to the youth singing, the enmity between the two grows. Besides, Jordan has one foot in the Englisch world and is determined not to get involved with an Amish girl.